Table of Contents
Where you are right now (clear state)
- CNA has not accepted or denied the claim
- They have sufficient information to decide
- They are using non-committal language (“potentially”)
- The engineer reports are already complete
- Additional emails will not force resolution
- Statute-of-limitations risk is real, not hypothetical
At this point, the claim process is functionally over, even though they won’t say it.
Step 2 — File a protective lawsuit (even if narrow)
- This is not escalation — it’s preservation.
Key points
- You do not need an attorney to file
- You do not need to perfect the case now
You only need:
- proper parties
- basic causes of action
- correct venue
- filing before SOL
- You can amend later.
- You can add counsel later.
- You can refine damages later.
But you cannot fix a missed deadline.
Step 3 — Venue & parties (clean approach)
Venue
Harrison County, Texas – District Court
- Chad Sims - Judge
Yes, even though the City is involved. This is normal. Courts handle this all the time.
✅ Harrison County, Texas
- Joe Black - Judge
This is not optional — it is correct and defensible.
- Property is located there
- Damages occurred there
- Defendants conducted business there
- Evidence and witnesses are there
Now the court level decision:
🏛️ District Court (recommended)
Harrison County District Court
Why District Court (not JP / County):
- Your damages exceed $250,000 potential exposure when properly pled
- Bad faith & Insurance Code claims belong here
- City + insurer + contractor together belongs here
- District Court avoids artificial damage caps and procedural traps
This also signals seriousness to CNA and future counsel.
✅ Decision: Harrison County District Court
Defendants (recommended)
- Casey Slone Construction, LLC
- Continental Casualty Company (CNA) (for bad faith / unfair claims handling)
- City of Marshall, Texas (for property damage under TTCA)
- Insurance Agency? Bockman Agency?
You can always nonsuit or sever later if needed.
Step 4 — Causes of action (keep it tight)
You do not need to allege everything under the sun.
Minimum viable filing:
Casey Slone Construction LLC Direct tortfeasor
- Negligence / property damage (construction activity causing flooding, sewer damage, structural harm)
- Negligent failure to protect adjoining property
- Texas Insurance Code §541.060 violations (delay, misrepresentation, failure to settle when liability reasonably clear)
- Trespass / nuisance (optional)
- Declaratory relief (optional, but useful)
Continental Casualty Company (CNA) Role: Bad faith & statutory violations
Claims:
- Texas Insurance Code §541.060
- Failure to attempt prompt, fair settlement
- Misrepresentation of coverage position
- Unreasonable delay
- Suppression of engineer reports
- Refusal to acknowledge or investigate the initial claim.
You have extraordinary documentation for this.
City of Marshall, Texas Role: Co-causing entity & TTCA liability Claims:
- Property damage caused by governmental function
- Negligent supervision
- Negligent failure to protect adjoining property
⚠️ Important: We plead only property damage, not discretionary acts. This avoids immunity dismissal.
That’s enough to stop the clock.
Step 5 — Service (don’t overthink this)
After filing:
- Clerk issues citation
Service via:
- registered agent (CSC, CNA)
- City Secretary / Mayor for City of Marshall
This can happen after filing. Service does not affect SOL — filing does.
Step 6 — Parallel move (optional but smart)
File a Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) complaint against CNA.
Why:
- It freezes their “we’re still reviewing” posture
- Forces a written response
- Creates regulatory pressure
- Costs you nothing
It runs parallel to litigation.
What you should not worry about right now
- Perfect pleading
- Final damage numbers
- Winning immediately
- How angry they’ll be
- Whether you’ll look “aggressive”
None of that matters at this stage.
One grounding truth (important)
They did not accidentally let this drag on. You are not overreacting by filing. Filing is the normal, expected response at this point.
They are betting you won’t. That’s the only leverage they have left.
If you want, next I can:
- Draft a bare-bones petition outline you can file pro se
- Help you choose District vs County court
- Map exact filing language to avoid immunity traps
- Or help you identify Texas firms that step in after filing
But from here forward, the direction is set.
