Private Review – CNA Reversal & Powell Contradictions

🧾 Key Document Overview

CNA Initial Report (June 27, 2024): Confirms construction caused sewer break, water intrusion, A/C failure, and brick damage.
CNA Supplemental Report (July 23, 2024): Reverses conclusion on sewer line, based on emails from Eric Powell and Casey Slone.
User Photographs: Show pipe was crushed, not misaligned. Break is not at pipe intersection. Refutes Powell’s “pipe-in-pipe” theory.

Powell claimed he could not legally comment on cause — but did, and that comment reversed a forensic engineer’s conclusion.
Powell’s “4" pushed into 6" pipe” theory is false. Photos show a crushed pipe in a straight section — not a junction or obstruction.
All pipes on the block transition from 4" to 6". This configuration is normal and does not cause blockages.
The supposed obstruction was never discussed in your conversations with Powell — but suddenly appears post-report.
The email Powell sent to Casey Slone or CNA is not included in the public records — suggesting concealment.
Powell was present during the repair and knew how the line broke. The new theory is either incompetence or deliberate misrepresentation.

Powell helped oversee the replacement of the sewer line. You paid for the materials.
All parties present, including Powell, observed the actual damage.
Public records request explicitly asked for all of Powell’s communications about your property.
The Powell email influencing the report was not disclosed — but was referenced by the engineer.

Engineer report reversal lacks scientific basis and relies solely on input from potentially liable parties.
Powell’s written comments directly contradict his verbal claims and firsthand knowledge.
The Powell email may constitute fraudulent misrepresentation and/or concealment of public records.
Recommended next step: Draft a formal rebuttal letter targeting CNA’s reversal and Powell’s role. Attach photographic proof and timeline of events.
Consider a supplemental Public Information Act request specifically targeting Powell's correspondence with Casey Slone and CNA.